AISLES Australian Law Network provides a unique experience for members to have increased access to justice.
AISLES produces a daily digest of cases coming out of Australian Courts in all jurisdictions giving our members the ability to maintain or increase their knowledge of Australian Law in a social media style environment.
Lawyers, Mediators and other related professionals join to keep their fingers on the pulse of the Court and to get access to cases that have been digested for a quick read for lawyers and get to show case their skills and provide legal services to members.
Members with an interest in the law get to read the plain English summary to get a feel for whether they want to know more about the cases and have access to Lawyers, Mediators and other professionals providing services that they can interact with in a social media setting discretely using anonymous profiles or contact them directly with their real profiles.
AISLES specialises in increasing access to justice by providing specialised Alternative Dispute Resolution processes that include mediation and pre-trial mentoring programs that ensure you are fully prepared.
Want to find out more? Book a free call to discuss your matter and discover the options available to you.
Join AISLES as a subscribed member here:
CLICK HERE TO JOIN
ASF17 v Commonwealth of Australia [2024] HCA 19 (10 May 2024)
Intro:-
This is an appeal from the Federal Court of Australia
Facts:-
The appellant, ASF17, is a citizen of Iran. He arrived in Australia as an unlawful non-citizen at the age of 27 in 2013. Except for a short period during which he held a bridging visa between 2013 and 2014, he has been held in immigration detention continuously since his arrival.
While in immigration detention, ASF17 in 2015 made an application for a Safe Haven Enterprise Visa ("SHEV"). The application was refused by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection in 2017. An application for judicial review of the decision of the delegate was dismissed by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia in 2017[4] in a decision which was upheld on appeal to the Federal Court of Australia in 2018.
The final determination of his application for a SHEV which occurred upon the dismissal of the appeal in 2018 engaged the duty imposed on officers of the Department of Home Affairs ("the Department") by s 198(6) of the Act to remove ASF17 from Australia as soon as reasonably practicable. Unlike the plaintiff in NZYQ, ASF17 has never formally requested to be removed from Australia so as to engage the other duty to remove imposed on officers of the Department by s 198(1) of the Act.
For the purpose of facilitating removal of ASF17 from Australia, officers of the Department conducted regular interviews with him from 2018. Throughout those interviews, he consistently told officers that he would not voluntarily return to Iran. He consistently refused to sign a request for removal or to engage with Iranian authorities in planning for his removal. He repeatedly told officers that he would agree to be sent to any country other than Iran. However, he did not suggest that there was any country to which he might be removed other than Iran.
Iranian citizens cannot enter Iran from Australia without a travel document issued by Iranian authorities and Iranian authorities have a longstanding policy of not issuing travel documents to involuntary returnees.
The Department has a policy of not removing anyone to a country in respect of which they have no right of residency or long-term stay ("the third country removal policy").
The consistent refusal of ASF17 to cooperate in facilitating his removal from Australia to Iran combined with his failure to identify any third country in which he might have a right of residency or long-term stay therefore resulted in an impasse. His position was described in a record of the Department in 2022 as "intractable".
In 2023, barely a week after the pronouncement of the orders in NZYQ, ASF17 applied to the Federal Court of Australia for a writ of habeas corpus on the basis that his continuing detention exceeded the constitutional limitation identified in those orders. In support of that application, ASF17 filed affidavits deposing that he is bisexual and that he feared being harmed in Iran because of his bisexuality. He had not claimed to fear being harmed in Iran because of his sexual orientation in his application for a SHEV in 2015 and the delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection had accordingly not considered it.
.
Responding to the application for a writ of habeas corpus, the Commonwealth accepted the burden of establishing that the continuing detention of ASF17 did not exceed the constitutional limitation identified in NZYQ. The Commonwealth sought to discharge that burden by establishing that ASF17 could be removed to Iran were he to cooperate in returning voluntarily to Iran.
The primary judge dismissed the application. ASF17 appealed from the decision of the primary judge to the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia under s 24 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The appeal was removed into this Court on the application of the Attorney-General of the Commonwealth under s 40(1) of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth).
Issue:-
Did continuing detention of appellant exceed constitutional limitation identified in NZYQ where appellant refused to cooperate in the undertaking of administrative processes necessary to facilitate his removal from Australia?
Consideration:-
The constitutional limitation unanimously expressed in NZYQ in terms that the constitutionally permissible period of executive detention of an alien who has failed to obtain permission to remain in Australia comes to an end when "there is no real prospect of removal of the alien from Australia becoming practicable in the reasonably foreseeable future" was unanimously explained in NZYQ to follow directly from the principle in Chu Kheng Lim v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs and to be an appropriate expression of the Lim principle in the context of the Act.
That explanation of the constitutional limitation was given in NZYQ against the background of the Lim principle having been unanimously explained to mean that "a Commonwealth statute which authorises executive detention must limit the duration of that detention to what is reasonably capable of being seen to be necessary to effectuate an identified statutory purpose which is reasonably capable of being achieved" and against the background of the application of the Lim principle having been further explained by six members of the Court to be "ultimately directed to a single question of characterisation", though one which requires an assessment of both means and ends.
The short point is that, conformably with the Lim principle, continuing detention for a non-punitive purpose that is occurring because of a voluntary decision of the detainee cannot be characterised as penal or punitive. The non‑punitive statutory purpose of removing an alien detainee from Australia under s 198(1) or s 198(6) of the Act remains a non-punitive purpose that is reasonably capable of being achieved if and for so long as removal could be achieved in the reasonably foreseeable future were the detainee to decide to cooperate in the undertaking of administrative processes necessary to facilitate that removal.
Conclusion:-
The statutory position of ASF17 is unambiguous. His removal from Australia is required by s 198(6) of the Act. In the absence of an extant protection finding, which would engage the operation of s 197C(3), his removal to Iran is permissible under s 198(6).
Appeal is dismissed with costs.
Miller v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 13 (17 April 2024)
Intro:-
This is an appeal from the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia
Facts:-
Mr Miller is a Fijian national whose Resident Return (Subclass 155) visa was cancelled under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ("the Migration Act"). A delegate of the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs ("the Minister") decided under s 501CA(4) of the Migration Act not to revoke that original decision on the basis that the delegate was not satisfied in terms of s 501CA(4)(b)(ii) that there was "another reason why the original decision should be revoked".
...
Calculating the period so fixed by s 500(6B) of the Migration Act in accordance with s 36 of Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth), the last day for Mr Miller to make an application to the Tribunal for review of the decision of the delegate was 25 March 2021.
Mr Miller's migration agent made an application to the Tribunal for review of the decision of the delegate on 24 March 2021. Apparently because the migration agent mistook the form approved by the President of the Tribunal to be used for making such an application, the application made by the migration agent contained no statement of the reasons for the application.
The Tribunal held a directions hearing on 1 April 2021 at which the Tribunal requested that Mr Miller provide reasons for the application. In response to that request, Mr Miller's solicitors emailed the Tribunal on 9 April 2021. Under the heading "Why do you claim the decision is wrong?", the email stated, "[t]he Minister erred in concluding that there is not another reason why the original decision to cancel the applicant's Resident Return (Subclass 155) visa should be revoked". There is no dispute that this statement would have been sufficient to comply with s 29(1)(c) of the AAT Act had it been contained in the application made on 24 March 2021.
Tribunal and decision of the Federal Court & Full Court
The Tribunal considered the application to have engaged its jurisdiction to review the decision of the delegate despite the application's non-compliance with s 29(1)(c) of the AAT Act and proceeded to review the decision of the delegate. The Tribunal ultimately decided to affirm the decision of the delegate.
Mr Miller applied to the Federal Court of Australia under s 476A of the Migration Act for judicial review of the decision of the Tribunal. On the hearing of the application for judicial review, the Minister conceded that, if the jurisdiction of the Tribunal was engaged, then its decision was affected by jurisdictional error, but contended that the non-compliance with s 29(1)(c) of the AAT Act meant that the application failed to engage the jurisdiction of the Tribunal at all.
The primary judge (Derrington J) accepted the contention of the Minister that the non-compliance with s 29(1)(c) of the AAT Act meant that the application failed to engage the jurisdiction of the Tribunal. His Honour ordered that a writ of certiorari be issued quashing the decision of the Tribunal and that the application for judicial review be otherwise dismissed. The Full Court of the Federal Court (Thawley, Halley and O'Sullivan JJ) dismissed an appeal from those orders. This appeal is by special leave from the decision of the Full Court.
Issue:-
Did non-compliance with the requirement of s 29(1)(c) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ("the AAT Act") – that an application to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal ("the Tribunal") for review of a decision "must contain a statement of the reasons for the application" – results in invalidity of the application such that the jurisdiction of the Tribunal to review the decision is not engaged?
Consideration:-
Project Blue Sky
In Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority,[18] McHugh, Gummow, Kirby and Hayne JJ explained:
"An act done in breach of a condition regulating the exercise of a statutory power is not necessarily invalid and of no effect. Whether it is depends upon whether there can be discerned a legislative purpose to invalidate any act that fails to comply with the condition. The existence of the purpose is ascertained by reference to the language of the statute, its subject matter and objects, and the consequences for the parties of holding void every act done in breach of the condition."
The explanation continued:
"Unfortunately, a finding of purpose or no purpose in this context often reflects a contestable judgment. The cases show various factors that have proved decisive in various contexts, but they do no more than provide guidance in analogous circumstances. There is no decisive rule that can be applied; there is not even a ranking of relevant factors or categories to give guidance on the issue."
Their Honours went on to observe that breach of a condition regulating the exercise of a statutory power which does not result in invalidity might nevertheless result in an unlawful act capable of being restrained by injunction.
Section 29(1)(c)
The answer to the ultimate question whether non-compliance with the condition of the making of an application to the Tribunal in s 29(1)(c) of the AAT Act – that an application contain a statement of the reasons for the application – results in invalidity of the application accordingly turns on the answer to the Project Blue Sky question whether there is to be discerned a legislative purpose to invalidate an application that fails to comply with that specific condition.
The starting point of the requisite analysis is to recognise that the circumstance that s 29(1)(c) of the AAT Act provides that an application "must" contain a statement of the reasons for the application is little more than that which poses the Project Blue Sky question. The use of that imperative terminology does not in the context of the AAT Act necessarily point to an affirmative answer.
Multiple considerations point inexorably to a negative answer. Unlike s 29(1)(a) of the AAT Act, which sets out how an application "must be made", s 29(1)(c) sets out information that an application which is made "must contain". The information to be provided in compliance with s 29(1)(c) is not as to any objective circumstance but is limited to the subjective reason of the applicant for making the application. In the language of s 29AB, it is at most information as to why the applicant believes that the decision sought to be reviewed is not the correct or preferable decision. That information is to be provided in the application notwithstanding that the very fact of the making of the application carries with it the necessary implication that the applicant is dissatisfied with the decision sought to be reviewed.
---
To discern within this overall context a legislative purpose to invalidate an application and thereby to deprive the Tribunal of jurisdiction for want of compliance with a condition which requires the provision of information entirely subjective to the applicant, compliance with which might be entirely inutile and non-compliance with which would be readily remediable by directions made by the Tribunal within jurisdiction, would be to attribute to the legislature an intention which would be arbitrary to the point of being capricious. Hardly needing to be repeated is that attribution of a legislative intention to produce a consequence which appears to be "absurd" or "capricious" or "irrational or unjust"[27] is to be avoided where the statutory text is not intractable.
Conclusion:-
Appeal allowed.

















