Defamation claim filed too early is dismissed: article was a fair summary of a coroner's decision
In Spencer v Australian Community Media & Ors [2026] VSC 738, the Supreme Court of Victoria (Watson J) dismissed a defamation proceeding brought by Dr Peter Spencer over a 2023 news article about a decision of the Victorian State Coroner. Dr Spencer filed his claim before the publisher's time to offer to make amends had run out, so he needed leave under s 12B(3) of the Defamation Act 2005 (Vic). The Court held that his concerns notices were valid, but refused leave because the claim had no real prospect of success: the article was a substantially accurate summary of the Coroner's decision. All paragraph references below are to the judgment.
Why it matters: Before suing for defamation, a person must send the publisher a "concerns notice" and then wait for the period in which the publisher can offer to make amends. This case explains how much detail that notice needs, and what happens if you sue too early.
At a glance
- Court and level: Supreme Court of Victoria, Common Law Division, Major Torts List, Watson J (first instance)
- Area of law: Defamation; Defamation Act 2005 (Vic) ss 12A, 12B, 26 and 28
- Decision type: Application for leave to commence a proceeding early, heard 24 July 2026, decided 16 November 2026
- Outcome: Leave refused and the proceeding dismissed as an abuse of process; costs to be agreed or argued in writing ([118]–[119])
- Standard applied: Whether it was "just and reasonable" to grant leave, including whether the claim had any reasonable prospect of success ([68], [89])
🧩 Facts and Issues
Background
The Canberra Times published the article on 9 June 2023, the day after the State Coroner published a decision following an inquest into the death of Dr Spencer's wife. Its headline said a charge had been "recommended" ([2], [9]). The first defendant, Australian Community Media (ACM), publishes The Canberra Times and was the only defendant served ([9]).
Much of Dr Spencer's complaint was really about the Coroner's decision itself ([3], [16]). His appeals against the Coroner's findings were unsuccessful ([5]). The Office of Public Prosecutions and Victoria Police later decided that no charges would be laid against him in relation to his wife's death ([6]).
The concerns notices
Between 27 May and 5 June 2024, Dr Spencer sent four documents described as concerns notices ([14]–[22]). On 4 June 2024 the publishers' solicitors replied that the article accurately reported the Coroner's decision, but removed it as a measure of good faith. They said the letters were not valid notices and asked for further particulars ([21]). Dr Spencer replied with a 16-page "updated concerns notice" ([22]).
In summary, Dr Spencer alleged that the article conveyed that the Coroner had recommended charges against him, that he was a criminal of low moral character and a violent criminal, that he was responsible for his wife's death, and that he had a history of family violence connected with it ([17], [43]). These were his allegations about what the article meant, not findings of the Court.
How the case got here
Dr Spencer filed this proceeding on 7 June 2024, two days after the fourth notice ([63]). In July 2025 he sought leave to have commenced it early ([11]). ACM argued that there was no valid concerns notice, that the limitation ground in s 12B(3)(a) did not apply, and that leave was not just and reasonable ([12]).
The issues
- Did Dr Spencer give a valid concerns notice under s 12A?
- Was leave available under s 12B(3)(a) or (b)?
- Could the Court consider the claim's prospects of success when deciding on leave?
⚖️ Applicable Law – Legislation, Rules and Principles
- Section 12A (concerns notice): a written notice that says where the matter can be accessed and "informs" the publisher of the imputations of concern and the harm the person considers to be serious harm to their reputation ([28]).
- Section 12A(3)–(5) (further particulars): if a notice is not adequately particularised, the publisher can ask for further particulars. If they are not provided within 14 days, no concerns notice is taken to have been given ([28]).
- Section 12B(1) (no early start): a proceeding cannot be commenced until a concerns notice has been given, the imputations relied on were particularised in it, and the "applicable period for an offer to make amends" has elapsed ([10]). That period is generally 28 days after the notice ([63]).
- Section 12B(3) (leave to sue early): the Court may grant leave only if waiting would breach the limitation law, or it is just and reasonable to grant leave ([10]).
- Limitation: a defamation claim is ordinarily due within one year of publication. A concerns notice given within 56 days of that deadline in effect gives a further 56 days from the notice ([65]).
- Section 18: a reasonable, timely offer to make amends that is not accepted can be a defence ([77]).
- Section 28 (public documents): it is a defence if the matter was a fair summary of, or extract from, a public document, such as a court's reasons. It is defeated only if the plaintiff proves the matter was not published honestly for the information of the public ([90]). Section 29 is similar for fair reports of proceedings of public concern, including coronial proceedings ([91]).
- Section 26 (contextual truth): a defence where substantially true imputations mean that the other imputations complained of do no further harm ([92]).
- Coroners Act 2008 (Vic) ss 49 and 69: a coroner must not say a person is or may be guilty of an offence, but must have the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) notified if the coroner believes an indictable offence may have been committed ([98]–[99]).
📌 Authorities Relied On
- Cooper v Nine Entertainment Co Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 726: a concerns notice is "not a pleading"; it is enough to identify the defamatory meanings complained of. Applied ([35]–[36], [42]).
- Staged Plus Pty Ltd v Yummi Fruit Ice-Creamery Pty Ltd [2024] QDC 88: its statement that imputations must be as precise as a pleading was not followed ([38]–[41]).
- Teh v Woodworth [2022] NSWDC 411 and M1 v R1 [2022] NSWDC 409: any requirement to particularise the causal link to serious harm was not followed ([58]–[59]).
- Reiter v News Corp Australia Pty Ltd [2025] VSC 54: the pre-action provisions aim to reduce the burden, cost and time of defamation disputes ([83], [85]).
- Gussen v Momentum Media Pty Ltd (No 2) [2026] FCA 1618: a fair summary must be substantially accurate, not perfect ([93]).
🧠 Analysis
Issue
Should Dr Spencer be given leave to continue a defamation claim he started before the publisher's time to offer amends had run out?
Rule
Leave under s 12B(3)(b) depends on all the circumstances, including the consequence of refusal, the plaintiff's explanation, prejudice to the defendant, and whether the claim has any reasonable prospect of success ([68]).
Application
The concerns notices were valid: substance over form
Section 12A requires the notice to "inform" the publisher, which focuses on substance, not formality ([32]). A publisher who does not ask for further particulars "could hardly be heard to complain" about a lack of precision ([33]). The first three notices showed the substance of the complaint, and the fourth, though "prolix and poorly structured", identified the imputations and the serious harm alleged: loss of his job, suspension of his registration and financial loss ([43]–[46], [60]). ACM's argument about further particulars elevated "form over substance" and failed ([61]–[62]).
He still sued too early, and the limitation ground did not apply
However the waiting period was calculated, the claim was filed too early and was liable to be dismissed without leave ([63]). Because of the 56-day extension, waiting would not have put him out of time, so s 12B(3)(a) was unavailable ([65]–[67]).
The explanation was not adequate, but ACM lost nothing
His first affidavit said he believed the limitation period would expire on 9 June 2024, an explanation that might generally help a self-represented litigant ([71]–[72]). His later affidavit said he knew of the extension, and the Court had "considerable doubts" about it because it was inconsistent with his earlier evidence ([73]–[74]). Overall the explanation was not adequate ([76]). On the other hand, ACM was not served during the amends period and simply chose not to make an offer, so it was not actually deprived of its s 18 defence ([80]).
The Court could look at the claim's prospects
Dr Spencer argued the only question was whether ACM had lost anything ([84]). The Court held that this was too narrow: letting a claim with no reasonable prospects proceed would be inconsistent with the purpose of reducing the cost and burden of defamation disputes ([85]–[86]). Courts take a similar approach to extending time and amending pleadings ([87]–[89]).
The article was a fair summary of the Coroner's decision
Comparing each sentence with the Coroner's decision, the Court found the article as a whole was a substantially accurate summary ([96]–[97]). The Coroner had recorded a belief, to the coronial standard, that an indictable offence may have been committed and directed that the DPP be notified ([100]).
Dr Spencer was right that the Coroner did not "recommend charges" ([101]). But for the ordinary reader, the difference between notifying the DPP and recommending charges was not "of great moment". Any damage came from what the Coroner actually said, and an accurate headline would have been no less damaging ([101]–[102]). A reference to recommended charges did not carry the pleaded imputation of guilt either ([104]). If that part had been unfair and defamatory, contextual truth under s 26 would answer it ([105]–[106]).
There was also no proper basis to say the article was not published honestly: his particulars were "surmise rather than substance" ([111]–[112]). The DPP's earlier view was not part of the Coroner's decision, and removing the article as a measure of good faith did not suggest dishonesty ([113]–[114]).
Conclusion
Having regard mainly to s 28, and also to ss 26 and 29, the claim had no real prospect of success, so leave was refused ([116], [118]).
🏛️ Outcome, Orders and Costs
Leave was refused, and the proceeding was dismissed as an abuse of process because it was commenced contrary to s 12B(1) ([118]). The parties must file consent orders on costs within seven days or, failing agreement, competing orders and short submissions ([119]).
🧭 Practical Lessons
- For self-represented litigants: A concerns notice need not look like a pleading, but it must clearly identify the material, the meanings complained of and the serious harm alleged ([32], [42], [60]).
- For self-represented litigants: Wait out the amends period before filing, and check the 56-day limitation extension first ([63], [65]–[67]).
- For self-represented litigants: Keep affidavit evidence consistent. Conflicting explanations hurt the application ([74]–[76]).
- For publishers: If a notice seems unclear, ask for further particulars ([33], [61]).
- For practitioners: On a s 12B(3)(b) application, expect the court to test the claim's prospects, including fair summary and contextual truth defences ([85]–[89], [116]).
🔗 Related on AISLES
- On journalists and the public's right to information: What the law says when police tell a journalist at a protest to move on.
- On courts weighing free expression against competing concerns: Harbour flotilla not prohibited: assembly rights outweighed real safety concerns.
🧠 Take-Home Lesson
- A concerns notice is judged on substance, not form, but the waiting period for an offer to make amends still matters.
- If you sue too early, leave is discretionary and can be refused where the claim has no real prospect of success.
- A substantially accurate summary of a court or coronial decision is strongly protected, even if one detail is not exactly right.
"Report what the decision actually says, and the law will usually protect the report. Sue on time, and sue on substance."
This digest is general information about a published judgment, not legal advice. For advice about your own situation, speak to a lawyer, Legal Aid or a community legal centre.