What the law says when police tell a journalist at a protest to move on
A letter of demand, published in full by Rebel News on 17 November 2026, says lawyers acting for journalist Avi Yemini have formally written to Victoria Police after he was, according to the letter, arrested twice at student protests outside the State Library of Victoria in Melbourne on 12 November 2026. The letter also includes a concerns notice under the Defamation Act 2005 (Vic). Nothing in the letter has been tested or proven in court, and as of the evening of 17 November 2026 AISLES could not find any public statement from Victoria Police about the letter itself. The move-on power discussed below is in section 6 of the Summary Offences Act 1966 (Vic).
This post is a companion to AISLES's digest of Commissioner of Police v Hodgson [2026] NSWSC 1452, also at aisles.com.au. Hodgson was a court's pre-event decision about a notified NSW assembly. This matter is different: a Victorian journalist's civil demand after move-on directions and arrests at a protest, with no court finding yet.
Why it matters: In Victoria, the everyday tools that decide what a journalist, or anyone else, can do at a protest include the move-on power, arrest without warrant, and the offence of hindering police. A letter of demand does not change that law.
At a glance
- Who: Avi Yemini, described in the letter as a journalist with Rebel News, and Victoria Police.
- Where: Student protests outside the State Library of Victoria, Melbourne, on 12 November 2026.
- What the letter alleges: Two arrests after a move-on direction; claims of false imprisonment and battery; and a defamation concerns notice about a Victoria Police statement. It says he was released without charge on both occasions.
- The letter's demands: $250,000 in compensation, legal costs, a written apology, an investigation of both arrests, and training on police powers and interactions with journalists at protests, with a response sought by Monday 23 November 2026.
📣 What has been alleged
Everything in this section is the account given in the letter. None of it has been proven.
- The letter says Mr Yemini attended the protests as a journalist to interview attendees and report on matters of public interest.
- It says that at around 3.30 pm a police officer asked him to move about 100 to 200 metres "for his safety, the protesters' safety and police safety", identified no specific threat or legal basis, and that he declined because he was peacefully reporting, with four professional security personnel. The letter says the same officer returned within about a minute, asked him to move again, and then ordered him arrested. It alleges he was tightly handcuffed, put in a divisional van, driven several blocks and then released.
- It says that at around 4 pm, while he was still several hundred metres from the protest and returning to continue reporting, officers formed a line across his path. According to the letter, an officer said that if he crossed it he would be arrested for hindering police, without identifying the duty allegedly hindered. The letter says he was then arrested again, taken to Melbourne West Police Station, and released without charge.
- The letter alleges swollen and bleeding wrists and a reinjured shoulder, and says that on neither occasion was he aggressive, nor did he threaten anyone or create a disturbance.
- It contends that both arrests were false imprisonment and that the use of force was battery: that there were no reasonable grounds for a move-on direction under section 6(1) of the Summary Offences Act 1966 (Vic), no basis for either arrest under section 458(1)(a) of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic), and that returning to the protest did not constitute hindering police under section 51 of the Summary Offences Act. It also refers to a 2022 written apology that, it says, acknowledged earlier wrongful arrests while he was reporting, and to a separate October 2026 incident that it says remains under investigation and is not part of this settlement offer.
🏛️ The police statement
The letter annexes a Victoria Police statement that, it says, was provided to journalists after a query about the arrest. The statement does not name Mr Yemini, but the letter says readers in that context would understand it to concern him. In the form annexed, it said:
Police had a presence at protest activity in Melbourne's CBD on 12 November. A 41-year-old man allegedly failed to comply with a direction to move on from officers and was detained in the vicinity of the State Library about 3.35pm. The man was moved to a location nearby and away from the protest activity. It is alleged the same man returned to the area of the protest activity. Despite the earlier direction to move on and subsequent warnings, the man allegedly attempted to pass directly through the officers. The man was arrested in relation to the alleged offence of hinder police. The man was released from custody a short time later and an investigation in relation to the incident remains ongoing.
AISLES has not independently verified either the letter or the statement, and it does not treat either account as a finding.
⚖️ Analysis
The account in the letter, and the legal conclusions it draws, are allegations only. What follows is the statutory framework a court would apply, not a finding about 12 November 2026.
Move-on directions. Section 6 of the Summary Offences Act 1966 (Vic) allows a police officer to direct a person in a public place to leave it, or part of it, if the officer "suspects on reasonable grounds" that the person is breaching or likely to breach the peace; is endangering or likely to endanger the safety of any other person; or that the person's behaviour is likely to cause injury, damage to property, or is otherwise a risk to public safety (s 6(1)). The direction may be given orally (s 6(2)), and may bar return for up to 24 hours (s 6(3)). Contravening it without reasonable excuse is an offence, carrying 5 penalty units (s 6(4)).
The power is not at large. Section 6(5) says the section does not apply to a person who, whether in company or not, is picketing a place of employment; demonstrating or protesting about a particular issue; or speaking, bearing or otherwise identifying with a banner, placard or sign, or otherwise behaving in a way apparently intended to publicise the person's view about a particular issue. Whether that exception applies depends on what the person was doing. The letter does not rely on section 6(5). It contends that the section 6(1) grounds were not present, and that refusing to comply with an unlawful direction is not itself an offence. Those are contentions, not findings. The statutory test is that the officer "suspects on reasonable grounds".
Arrest without warrant. Section 458(1)(a) of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) allows any person, including a police officer, to arrest without warrant a person they find committing an offence, but only where they believe on reasonable grounds that the apprehension is necessary to ensure court attendance, to preserve public order, to prevent continuation or repetition of the offence or a further offence, or for the safety or welfare of the public or of the offender. For a summary offence, section 458(3) requires release when that reason no longer continues, even if the person has not been charged. The letter contends that neither arrest met section 458.
Hindering police. Section 51(2) of the Summary Offences Act provides that a person must not assault, resist, obstruct, hinder or delay an emergency worker, custodial officer or youth justice custodial worker on duty. The penalty is 60 penalty units or imprisonment for 6 months. A police officer is an "emergency worker" under section 10AA(8) of the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic), and is "on duty" when performing any duty or exercising any power as such an officer (Sentencing Act s 10AA(9); Summary Offences Act s 51(7)). The annexed police statement said the man was arrested in relation to the alleged offence of hinder police. The letter denies that any hindering occurred.
False imprisonment and battery. These are civil claims in tort. False imprisonment is the unlawful total restraint of a person's liberty. Battery is a voluntary act that causes contact with another person without lawful justification. Lawful arrest, and reasonable force used to effect it, can supply a justification. The letter alleges both torts. Whether any detention or contact was justified has not been decided.
The defamation concerns notice. The letter is also a concerns notice under Part 3, Division 1 of the Defamation Act 2005 (Vic). The imputation it alleges is that Mr Yemini "wilfully committed the criminal offence of hindering police in the execution of their duty". He denies it. Section 10A makes serious harm to reputation an element of the cause of action. Section 12B generally provides that a defamation proceeding cannot be commenced until a concerns notice has been given and the applicable period for an offer to make amends has elapsed. That period is 28 days from when the publisher was given the notice, unless further particulars were later provided (s 14(2)). A court may grant leave to start earlier in limited circumstances (s 12B(3)). Any proposed Supreme Court filing on 24 November would concern the arrest tort claims. A defamation proceeding would ordinarily have to wait until the 28-day period has elapsed.
How this sits with Hodgson. Hodgson was a pre-event decision under Part 4 of the Summary Offences Act 1988 (NSW), in which the Court refused a section 25 application to prohibit a notified assembly after balancing assembly rights against genuine safety concerns. This matter arises under different Victorian statutes, after the event, and no court has yet been asked to decide it. The common thread is only this: police powers at protests are statutory, they have limits, and those limits are for a court to apply to proven facts.
🔜 What happens next
The letter asks Victoria Police to respond by Monday 23 November 2026, and says that if the settlement terms are not accepted, proceedings will be issued. A post by Mr Yemini on X on 17 November 2026, linking to the Rebel News article, said his legal team was preparing a statement of claim to file in the Supreme Court on Tuesday 24 November if the matter is not settled. That timetable, if followed, would relate to the civil claims arising from the arrests, not the defamation claim. As of the evening of 17 November 2026, AISLES could not find any public statement from Victoria Police about this letter. The mid-November statement annexed to the letter said an investigation remained ongoing.
💡 Take-Home Lesson
In Victoria, a police move-on direction at a protest is not a free-standing power to clear a public place. It depends on the officer suspecting, on reasonable grounds, one of the grounds in section 6 of the Summary Offences Act 1966 (Vic), and section 6(5) carves out picketing, demonstrating or protesting, and publicising a view. Arrest without warrant still has to meet the tests in section 458 of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic), and hindering police is a specific offence with its own elements. A letter of demand is not a court finding.
📚 Sources
- Rebel News, publishing the letter of demand in full, 17 November 2026: rebelnews.com
- Thomsons Lawyers, letter of demand and concerns notice to Victoria Police for Avi Yemini, 17 November 2026, including Annexure A
- Avi Yemini, post on X, 17 November 2026, linking to the Rebel News article
- AISLES digest of Hodgson: aisles.com.au
- Commissioner of Police v Hodgson [2026] NSWSC 1452: AustLII
- Summary Offences Act 1966 (Vic), authorised version 149: legislation.vic.gov.au
- Crimes Act 1958 (Vic), authorised version 324: legislation.vic.gov.au
- Defamation Act 2005 (Vic), authorised version 006: legislation.vic.gov.au
- Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic), authorised version 234: legislation.vic.gov.au
This digest is general information about a lawyer's letter and the legislation it raises. It is not legal advice, and it does not suggest that any allegation is true or untrue, or that any arrest, direction or statement was or was not lawful. For advice about your own situation, speak to a lawyer, Legal Aid or a community legal centre.