Ignoring court orders sent by email and messaging apps: civil contempt found in the defendant's absence
In AB v CD (No 3) [2026] NSWSC 1503, the Supreme Court of New South Wales (Richmond J) decided a contempt motion brought by the plaintiff against the first defendant, after a hearing that went ahead in her absence. The Court found, beyond reasonable doubt, that the first defendant, CD, was guilty of civil contempt on both charges: she had deliberately failed to deliver up certain property and to give discovery, as earlier orders required. Penalty has not yet been decided. All paragraph references below are to the judgment.
Why it matters: A person cannot escape court orders by refusing to engage. Orders sent by email, text and social media under substituted service can found a contempt finding, and the charge can be heard without the person charged if they know of the hearing and choose to stay away.
At a glance
- Court and level: Supreme Court of New South Wales, Equity Division, Duty List, Richmond J (first instance)
- Area of law: Civil contempt (breach of court orders); civil procedure (substituted service; hearing in a party's absence)
- Decision type: Contempt motion, heard 19 November 2026, decided 20 November 2026
- Outcome: CD was found guilty of civil contempt on both charges; a declaration will be made, and penalty will be decided at a separate hearing ([47]–[49])
- Standard applied: Beyond reasonable doubt ([32])
- Anonymisation: as the Court does, this digest uses AB, CD and EF, and refers to the publisher and the journalist by role only
🧩 Facts and Issues
Background
This is the third published decision in these proceedings; the second, AB v CD (No 2) [2026] NSWSC 1483, concerned a notice to produce served on the publisher and the journalist.
The plaintiff, AB, alleges that CD has possession of certain property holding AB's confidential information, and that AB never allowed her to take it or use the information ([8]). AB started the proceedings in late October 2026, after a news article was published by the second defendant (the publisher) and written by the third defendant (the journalist) ([9]–[10]). Those claims are allegations only; this decision does not determine them.
The papers were sent to CD by email, text and social media messages ([10]). Two days later, the Court made the orders at the centre of this decision ([11]):
- a Delivery Order, requiring CD to deliver up the property to AB's solicitors by 4.00 pm on Monday 2 November 2026; and
- a Discovery Order, requiring CD to give discovery by verified list of documents and communications involving the confidential information by 4.00 pm on Wednesday 4 November 2026.
Both orders were endorsed with a penal notice, which warns that disobedience may be punished as contempt. CD did not appear at that hearing ([11]).
Repeated notice, no response
The judgment records many attempts to bring the orders to CD's attention ([13]–[16], [21]–[24]):
- the orders were sent to her by email and several messaging and social media services, starting before the deadlines expired ([13], [40]);
- on 4 November 2026 she was told, through six channels, that she was in breach and that the orders carried a penal notice ([14]);
- she was told of the contempt hearing date by several means ([15], [22]);
- a process server who went to a friend's home gave evidence that, when the friend telephoned her, CD told him not to accept anything ([16]);
- on 12 November 2026 she again did not appear; the Court directed her to attend on 19 November 2026 and ordered a bench warrant, but vacated it until a residential address could be found ([21]), which subpoenas had not yet achieved ([24]).
CD had been actively using several of the accounts used to contact her ([23]). She gave no discovery, did not deliver up the property, sought no extension, and did not communicate with AB's side at all ([25]).
The charge
The charge alleged civil contempt by failing to comply with both orders ([26]). AB sought a declaration, a bench warrant and a listing for sentence ([1]). CD did not appear on 19 November 2026, although her name was called three times ([2]).
The issues
- Could the motion be heard in CD's absence?
- Were the orders clear enough, and did CD know of them?
- Was her failure to comply deliberate, and was compliance possible?
⚖️ Applicable Law – Legislation, Rules and Principles
- Civil contempt: Disobeying a court order is a civil contempt that a party can enforce. Its sanctions mainly aim to secure compliance, not to punish ([27]).
- The five elements: The plaintiff must prove that the Court made an order; that its terms are clear, unambiguous and capable of compliance; that it was served (or service was excused or dispensed with); that the person charged knew its terms; and that they breached it ([28]).
- Knowledge: Knowing the substance of the order is enough; the person need not have understood that their conduct was a breach ([29]).
- Deliberate breach: No specific intent to disobey is needed, but the breach must be deliberate, not casual, accidental or unintentional ([30]). Failing to take steps to comply cannot be called accidental ([31]).
- Standard of proof: Each element must be proved beyond reasonable doubt ([32]–[33]).
- Impossibility: Impossibility of compliance may be a defence, but the person charged must show it ([34]).
- Service and absence: Substituted service is sufficient, but proceeding in the absence of the person charged is a cautious discretion ([35]–[36]).
📌 Authorities Relied On
- Dowling v Prothonotary (2018) 99 NSWLR 229: civil contempt sanctions aim to secure compliance ([27]).
- National Australia Bank Ltd v Juric [2001] VSC 375: the five elements of contempt by breach of an order ([28]).
- Markisic v Commonwealth (2007) 69 NSWLR 737: what makes a breach deliberate ([30]).
- Witham v Holloway (1995) 183 CLR 525: contempt must be proved beyond reasonable doubt ([32]).
- Doyle v Commonwealth (1985) 156 CLR 510: substituted service is sufficient for contempt proceedings ([35]).
- Ronowska v Kus (No 2) [2012] NSWSC 817: the discretion to hear a contempt charge in the absence of the person charged ([36]).
🧠 Analysis
Issue
Was it appropriate to hear the charge without CD, and was each element of contempt proved beyond reasonable doubt for both orders?
Rule
Substituted service will do for contempt, but proceeding in a person's absence is a cautious discretion ([35]–[36]). Each of the five elements must be proved beyond reasonable doubt for each order ([28], [32], [38]).
Application
Proceeding in CD's absence
The Court decided at the outset that the motion could go ahead without CD ([35]). First, she had been served with the motion, charge and evidence under orders for substituted service, which was enough even without personal service ([35]). Second, it is appropriate to proceed where the person charged has voluntarily agreed to the hearing going ahead without them ([36]). The Court was satisfied CD had done so: she knew of the hearing and chose to ignore it, took no part despite many attempts to involve her, and was evading service ([37]).
The Delivery Order
- Made and clear: The order carried a penal notice ([38]) and required one act: delivering a specified item to a specified place by a specified time. CD could not have doubted what was required, as she had already been ordered to deliver up the same item in earlier, separate proceedings ([39]).
- Knowledge: The orders and penal notice were sent many times to accounts she demonstrably used, and wilful blindness is no answer. The Court found she knew of the order before the deadline, and at the latest by 4 November 2026, and that she was evading personal service ([40]).
- Deliberate breach: She had not delivered the item, sought an extension or communicated at all. A person who takes no step to comply cannot say the breach was accidental, and her failure was deliberate ([41]).
- Capacity to comply: CD had not met her evidential onus to raise impossibility. In any event, given what the Court called the "extraordinary litigation history", it found that she had kept the item and chosen not to deliver it ([42]).
The Discovery Order
- Clear: The order required a verified list by a fixed time, and the class of documents was clearly defined. It was simple and capable of compliance "whatever documents" CD held ([43]).
- Knowledge: The orders were sent to her on 29 and 30 October and 2 November 2026, before the deadline, and she was told on 4 November 2026 that she was in breach ([44]).
- Deliberate breach: No verified list was served, though that needed only preparing and swearing a document. Her "total inaction", after repeated notice and a penal notice, was deliberate ([45]).
- Capacity to comply: The order could be met whatever documents CD held, so AB did not need to prove any existed, and CD raised no impossibility ([46]).
Conclusion
Every element was proved beyond reasonable doubt for both orders: CD was guilty on both charges ([47]).
🏛️ Outcome, Orders and Costs
The Court will make the declaration of contempt sought, and directed AB to bring in short minutes, including a timetable for a penalty hearing ([49]).
Penalty has not been decided. AB's senior counsel accepted that there should be a separate penalty hearing and said the penalty sought would be imprisonment until the contempt is purged. The Court said that penalty was "certainly" open, given the seriousness of the contempt ([48]). Because civil contempt sanctions aim to secure compliance ([27]), a contempt of this kind can ordinarily be purged by complying with the orders. The judgment does not say what CD would need to do, or how that would affect penalty.
The bench warrant and sentence listing sought in the motion ([1]) are left to the short minutes and penalty hearing ([49]). Costs are not addressed.
The judgment does not discuss appeal or set-aside rights. In general, under r 36.16(2)(b) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), the Court may set aside an order made in a party's absence, but the applicant must usually explain the absence and show an arguable case. An appeal may also be possible.
The underlying claims about the confidential information have not been decided; this decision concerns only CD's failure to comply with the two orders.
🧭 Practical Lessons
- For anyone served with court orders: Ignoring orders, or staying out of reach, will not make them go away. If you cannot comply, apply promptly for an extension or variation, and tell the other side ([25], [41]).
- For anyone served electronically: Orders sent to accounts you actively use, under substituted service, can be enough ([23], [35], [40]).
- For self-represented litigants: If you stay away, the Court may find you chose to let the hearing go ahead without you ([36]–[37]).
- For practitioners: Keep a dated record of every attempt at service and notice; that evidence carried the findings here ([13]–[16], [22]–[23], [37], [40]).
🔗 Related on AISLES
- The earlier ruling in these proceedings, about a notice to produce served on the publisher and the journalist: Shield law no bar to a notice to produce: redaction can protect a journalist's source.
- On the costs consequences of a contempt motion: Seven Network seeks Cost Orders of $152,156 against Kangaroo Court blogger Shane Dowling.
🧠 Take-Home Lesson
- A court order binds you whether or not you engage with the proceedings.
- Orders sent by email, text or social media under substituted service can be enough, and a contempt charge can be heard without you if you knowingly stay away.
- Total inaction after repeated notice and a penal notice can be deliberate contempt, proved beyond reasonable doubt.
"Ignoring a court order does not make it go away. If you cannot comply, ask the Court for more time, before the deadline passes."
This digest is general information about a published judgment, not legal advice. For advice about your own situation, speak to a lawyer, Legal Aid or a community legal centre.