·   ·  33 posts
  • A

    B

    A

    609 friends

Hotel's ATM settlements and beer rebates diverted to a family company: manager ordered to repay $1.18 million

After a trial, the NSW Supreme Court found that a hotel's former manager dishonestly diverted ATM settlements and beer rebates owed to the company that ran the hotel into his family company's account, and ordered both to repay about $1.18 million. Most missing-cash claims failed.

In Gratory Pty Ltd (recs and mgrs apptd) v Pastrello (No 2) [2026] NSWSC 1485, the Supreme Court of New South Wales (Sirtes J) gave judgment after a five-day trial of a company's claims against the former manager of its hotel and his family company over hotel income paid into the family company's bank account. The Court found that the manager, Mr Robert Pastrello, dishonestly caused ATM settlements and beer rebates owed to the company to be paid to his family company, and gave judgment for about $1.18 million. Most of the company's separate claims about missing cash failed. All paragraph references below are to the judgment.

Why it matters: This is a final decision after a trial, not an interlocutory ruling. It shows that a person who runs a business for its owner can owe officer and fiduciary duties before becoming a director, that a family company receiving diverted money can be made to repay it, and that pleading fraud makes a case harder to prove.

At a glance

  • Court and level: Supreme Court of New South Wales, Equity Division, Sirtes J (first instance, after a trial in August 2026)
  • Area of law: officers' duties under ss 181 and 182 Corporations Act 2001 (Cth); fiduciary duties and knowing receipt; standard of proof
  • Decision: 19 November 2026
  • Outcome: Judgment of $1,180,763.52 plus interest; most cash claims failed; costs reserved ([4], [406])
  • Standard applied: The balance of probabilities, applied with the care that serious allegations of fraud require ([127]–[128])

🧩 Facts and Issues

Background

The company, Gratory Pty Ltd, operated a country hotel owned by Mr Pastrello's late father, who was its sole director and shareholder ([1]–[2], [7]). Mr Pastrello, the licensee since 2013, increasingly ran the hotel day to day as his father's health declined ([10]–[12]). He and his siblings became directors in February 2019 ([19]). Since 2024, court-appointed receivers and managers have controlled the company and brought these proceedings ([2], [29], [33]).

The second defendant, La Serenissima Pty Ltd, is owned and controlled by Mr Pastrello and his wife, and is the trustee of their family trust ([2]). Claims against a third defendant were settled at mediation ([2], [36]).

What the company alleged

The company alleged that Mr Pastrello took the hotel's money in two ways ([3], [40]–[41]):

  • by misappropriating cash takings over about five years, said to total more than $2.4 million; and
  • by causing ATM settlements and fees from the ATM provider, and volume rebates and a venue payment from the hotel's beer supplier, to be paid into his family company's account instead of the company's, and by causing the company to pay for goods for his own use.

It also alleged that the family company was liable as a "knowing recipient" of the diverted money ([43]). The pleading described Mr Pastrello's conduct as a "fraudulent and dishonest design" ([42]).

What the defendants said

The defendants denied wrongdoing. They said that before 2019 the hotel was the father's business, that any undeposited cash was used for the business, and that the rebates were part of Mr Pastrello's pay ([3], [44]–[46]). Mr Pastrello did not give evidence and abandoned his cross-claim for employee entitlements ([38]).

The issues

  • Was the company the proper plaintiff for money earned before 2019?
  • Did Mr Pastrello owe duties before becoming a director?
  • Did the company have to prove dishonesty, and to what standard?
  • Were the ATM payments, rebates, personal purchases and cash dishonestly taken?
  • Was the family company liable as a knowing recipient?

⚖️ Applicable Law – Legislation, Rules and Principles

  • Who is an "officer": under s 9AD(1)(b) of the Corporations Act, an officer includes a person who takes part in decisions affecting a substantial part of the business or can significantly affect its financial standing. The test is the role actually played, not the title ([254]–[256]).
  • Statutory duties: directors and officers must act in good faith in the company's best interests (s 181), and must not improperly use their position to gain an advantage (s 182, which also covers employees) ([142], [276]–[277]).
  • Fiduciary duties: a fiduciary must avoid conflicts between duty and interest and must not profit from the position without consent. Mere carelessness is not a fiduciary breach ([135]–[136]). Senior employees can be fiduciaries ([248]–[249]).
  • Knowing receipt (first limb of Barnes v Addy): a third party that receives property transferred in breach of fiduciary duty, knowing of the breach, must account for it. Constructive notice is not enough ([369]–[370]).
  • Standard of proof: civil claims are decided on the balance of probabilities, but under s 140 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) and Briginshaw, a fraud allegation needs stronger evidence ([127]–[129]).
  • A party's silence: under Jones v Dunkel, a party's unexplained failure to give evidence lets an available inference be drawn more confidently, but cannot fill gaps in the evidence ([151]–[155]).

📌 Authorities Relied On

  • Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336: serious allegations need cogent proof ([127]–[128]).
  • Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298 and Kuhl v Zurich Financial Services Australia Ltd (2011) 243 CLR 361: the limits on inferences from silence ([151], [154]).
  • Australian Securities and Investments Commission v King (2020) 270 CLR 1: who is an officer depends on the role actually played ([256], [259]).
  • Farah Constructions Pty Ltd v Say-Dee Pty Ltd (2007) 230 CLR 89: what dishonesty means, and the elements of liability under Barnes v Addy ([227]–[228], [369]).
  • Simmons v New South Wales Trustee and Guardian [2014] NSWCA 405: the elements of knowing receipt ([369]).
  • Blue Mirror Pty Ltd v Tan & Tan Australia Pty Ltd (in liq) [2024] NSWCA 253: a director's knowledge is attributed to the company through which he acts ([373]).

🧠 Analysis

Issue

Had the company proved, to the standard required for fraud, that Mr Pastrello dishonestly diverted or took its money, and was his family company liable for what it received?

Rule

Because the company pleaded a "fraudulent and dishonest design", dishonesty was an element of every breach alleged against Mr Pastrello, and it had to be proved to the Briginshaw standard ([126], [131]). Unaccounted-for money alone was not enough ([131]–[132]).

Application

The company was held to its fraud pleading

Counsel said in opening that the company did not "press" the fraudulent design claim, but its solicitors later confirmed nothing was abandoned ([117], [121], [123]). The Court held the fraud case remained. Abandoning it would have left no pleaded breach, because dishonesty was built into each one ([124], [126]). A claim for unaccounted-for money or poor cash records might have been easier to prove, but was not pleaded ([131]).

The hotel was the company's business

Although much revenue passed through the father's personal account, the hotel traded under the company's name, its tax was reported by the company, and key supplier contracts were in the company's name. The company was the proper plaintiff ([220], [224]).

Mr Pastrello owed duties before he became a director

As a senior employee, he owed fiduciary duties over the hotel's cash and its dealings with the ATM provider and the brewer ([250]–[252]). From March 2016 he was also an "officer": he committed the company to major agreements and decided which account the ATM settlements went to ([259]–[260]). He was not a shadow director, because his father did not act on his instructions ([263]).

The ATM settlements were dishonestly diverted

Between 2016 and 2019, 102 ATM payments totalling $793,970.40 went to the family company's account ([231]). The Court found that Mr Pastrello knew the money was the hotel's, signed each redirection form, and kept the account out of the family company's financial statements ([268], [272]). His silence let the inference of dishonesty be drawn more confidently ([269]). That some money may have paid hotel suppliers did not change the diversion's character ([270]–[271]). The Court found breaches of fiduciary duty and of ss 181(1) and 182(1) ([278]–[279]).

The beer rebates were not his pay

The father's 2018 statements that he wanted his son to have the rebates did not prove an agreement, and no board approval was suggested after 2019 ([285]–[286]). Mr Pastrello's sworn cross-claim put his pay at $120,000 a year, with no mention of rebates ([287]). Even if he had been entitled to them, that would not explain payment to his family company ([289]). The Court found the $382,937.72 in rebates and the venue payment was diverted knowingly and dishonestly ([293]–[296]).

Personal purchases: partly proved

A wine subscription and a meat order delivered to his home at the company's expense ($3,855.40) were found to be dishonest diversions. The premium wine claim failed: nobody proved who ordered it or where it went ([300]–[304]).

The cash claims mostly failed

The receivers' reconciliation showed shortfalls, but not who took any cash or why ([312]). For the earliest and latest periods, misappropriation was not proved; similar shortfalls appeared when Mr Pastrello was not handling cash ([326]–[330], [362]–[363]). For a period in 2022–23, video footage and a recorded conversation led the Court to find he dishonestly took cash, but the amount could not be fixed ([348], [351]). Quantification evidence served about a week before trial was excluded, and a further inquiry was refused as "a second bite at the cherry" ([37], [399]–[400]).

The family company was a knowing recipient

The family company received money belonging in equity to the hotel company. Mr Pastrello's knowledge was attributed to it as one of its two directors ([372]–[373]). Its counsel accepted that its liability would follow if the case against him succeeded ([367]). It was liable for $1,176,908.12, jointly with him, whether or not it still held the money ([374]–[375], [377]).

Conclusion

The company won on the ATM payments, rebates, venue payment and two personal items, but not on most cash claims or the premium wine. The 2022–23 cash finding produced no order ([4], [305], [365], [402]).

🏛️ Outcome, Orders and Costs

The Court declared that Mr Pastrello, in breach of his fiduciary duties, dishonestly caused the ATM payments, the rebates and venue payment, and $3,855.40 of personal purchases to be diverted. It gave judgment of $1,176,908.12 against him and the family company jointly, plus $3,855.40 against him alone, with interest ([406]). No credit or allowance was made for money said to be spent on the hotel or for his work, as he gave no evidence for either ([385]–[387]). A Corporations Act contravention declaration was declined because only ASIC can seek one ([393]–[394]). Costs and interest will be decided on written submissions ([404]–[406]). The decision may be appealed.

🧭 Practical Lessons

  • For small business owners: Make sure supplier, rebate and payment-provider contracts name the business and pay into its own account, and check regularly where those payments actually go ([220], [233], [268]).
  • For small business owners: A trusted manager can owe officer and fiduciary duties even without a director title ([252], [260]).
  • For managers and family members: Believing the owner "would have approved" is not enough. Get clear, documented approval for any pay or benefit ([285]–[286], [294]).
  • For self-represented litigants: Pleading fraud raises the bar. If you allege dishonesty, you must prove it with cogent evidence ([126], [131]).
  • For practitioners: Serve quantification evidence in time; late expert evidence was excluded and an inquiry refused ([37], [399]).

🧠 Take-Home Lesson

  • Anyone who runs a company's business can owe it officer and fiduciary duties, with or without the title of director.
  • Redirecting the business's receipts to your own company, without clear approval, can be found dishonest, and the receiving company can be ordered to repay.
  • Unexplained shortfalls are not enough on their own: a claimant who alleges fraud must prove it with cogent evidence.
"Pay the business's money into the business's account. If it goes anywhere else, the person who directed it, and the company that received it, may have to pay it back."

This digest is general information about a published judgment, not legal advice. For advice about your own situation, speak to a lawyer, Legal Aid or a community legal centre.

Comments (0)
Login or Join to comment.
SSL Certificates